I know I’ve written about sweets and baking mostly, but with the weather starting to turn cool but summer produce still plentiful, it seemed like a perfect weekend to try making something new—tomato sauce. I had a bunch of tomatoes from my own garden and supplemented them with a bunch of tomatoes purchased at a farmer’s market.
Yum! Look at these tomatoes!
I’ve never made sauce before, but I’ve made soups, so I figured I could handle this. I also did something great, which was to crowd source on Facebook. I can count many great cooks among my friends, I’m happy to say, and got some great advice on what to add, what to avoid and how to really bring out the best of the flavors I was using. I actually got so much good advice that I’m looking forward to trying this again to use all that information.
For the basic steps of making a sauce, I started with the about.com recipe.This was a great reference for me. What you’ll need:
- Tomatoes (it’s amazing how much this cooks down so for all this work, you should get a lot of tomatoes!)
- Onions, chopped finely
- Carrots, chopped finely
- Garlic, chopped finely
- Basil, chopped
- Salt
- Pepper
- Olive oil
- 1 Bay leaf
- Wine (this is optional… you can also use balsamic vinegar or something else acidic. A friend said this helps the flavor to pop and she was right!)
You’re also going to need some tools. So, if this is your first time, here’s some stuff you’re going to need:
- A big pot. Maybe two, so you can use one for tomato prep and the other, bigger one for the sauce.
- A colander
- A long, sturdy mixing tool. I used a grilling tool at first for mixing then switched over to a long-handled spoon as the mixture cooked down.
- Several large bowls
Many people spoke up against adding sugar. On the advice of one friend, I added some carrots for sweetness instead and it turned out well. Another great piece of advice was to add more garlic than I thought I should. I’m also lucky that I grow my own basil, so I had plenty of fresh basil to use.
I put in a few tomatoes at a time to avoid crowding.
So… first step, prep the tomatoes. I had about 30-40 tomatoes. Other than the actual cooking down of the sauce, this was the longest step. Boil a big pot of water, and then put the tomatoes in for a few minutes to loosen the skins. Some people score the bottom of the tomato with an X to help the skin pull back. I didn’t, but on some of my tomatoes I wish I had.
When you pull them out, rinse them with cold water and drain them. Seriously, you’re going to drain the tomatoes 10 times and still have a ridiculous amount of water on them. Once they’re cool enough, remove the stems, skin and seeds. This is messy. If you compost, add all your skins and seeds for that. If not, I was happy to have a garbage disposal for everything. Did I mention this step was messy?
Once I was done with this, I heated up the pot with the olive oil (1/4 cup) and sautéed the onions (3 medium), carrots (I used 3), and garlic to soften them up. I think in the future I’d puree these afterwards so my final sauce wouldn’t be so distinct, but that doesn’t detract.
Most of that liquid will go away.
Next, add those tomatoes to the mixture, along with the basil, salt and pepper. Be careful – this step can be messy if you aren’t! Mix this together and let it come to a boil.
Reduce the heat and leave it to simmer. Stir occasionally. Use this time to clean up the dirty dishes, make a quilt, learn a new language, read a book, watch a football game or take a nap. I kept this on the lowest temperature I can get on my stove. I cooked it most of Saturday afternoon and another few hours on Sunday to get it to the consistency I wanted.
When it was the consistency I wanted, I added about a third cup of wine (I used a cabernet sauvignon), mixed it up, and let it cook down again. After all that work, I couldn’t resist having some right away. DELICIOUS!!!
Definitely worth the effort!
While the number of tomatoes I used didn’t leave me with enough jars to say goodbye to that supermarket aisle, it did give me the confidence and the ability to try to make more next year.
One note… I’ve never done canning (next time?) and didn’t make enough to have to worry about it, but if you do make enough to worry about that, it doesn’t seem that difficult. Just be careful—nobody needs botulism!
For the experienced readers, what advice do you have for novices?